Changes in Counselling Profession

I have seen various developments and changes within counselling profession over the last 15 years. More courses are available, British Association of Counselling and Psychotherapy (BACP) membership has vastly increased and more counsellors are becoming private practitioners.  Counsellors and organisations have to market themselves and approach their counselling work with a business head. Online counselling has grown with many counsellors now providing this along their face to face work. We have seen the increase of social media and people having the confidence to voice their opinions.  This in turn has meant counselling is becoming more popular and slowly breaking down the taboo of mental health.

Within counselling chat forums and social media there are a couple of issues that dominate the boards:

  1. Whether it is necessary to gain British Association of Counsellor and Psychotherapy (BACP) Accreditation
  2. The merits of swapping membership (BACP) with National Counselling Society (NCS) membership.

What are the changes that have lead to these two questions?

The main changes in the counselling profession

  1. Long debate about Regulation

As I mention in my article about regulation, when I was a student we often talked about it in our lessons and I remember I was one of the few trainees that in principle supported the idea of regulation. How and what form that should take, I wasn’t sure (and I’m still not!). One of the main arguments against formal regulation was that my peers felt regulation would not necessarily stop client abuse. Additionally regulation implies medical values which came be seen as opposing the rich varied use of counselling and psychotherapy approaches. However, one thing we all agree on is that our clients do need protecting. The debate on regulation continues.

  1. Introduction of Professional Standards Authority (PSA)

Instead of regulation there has been the development of the Accredited Register (formerly known as the Accredited Voluntary Register). The Register was set up by the Department of Health to ensure that the public are able to choose safe, ethical, adept professionals for their health and social care needs. Both NCS and BACP have had its register of Accredited Counsellors accredited by the Professional Standards Authority. Memberships to these two bodies have different routes with (in my opinion) the BACP’s route being more rigorous.  As Philip Dore writes about in his website unsafe spaces, this accredited register isn’t necessarily robust. Counsellors struck off from the BACP register due to client abuse are still practising. If the word counsellor or psychotherapist was protected, would it stop abuse?

  1. Development of another Counselling professional Body

Back in 1999 the National Counselling Society (NCS) was formed. It was set up by a group of counsellors and psychotherapists who found BACP wasn’t serving their needs.

What is the difference between BACP and NCS?

changes counselling-professionAs seen from the question at the beginning counsellors are confused to which professional organisation they should join. The route to membership of these two organisations is different. BACP you have to attend a 450 taught counselling course whereas NCS is happy to accept members who have only done 200 taught hours. Additionally the route for individual Accreditation is different. For BACP you have to have carried out 450 counselling hours as well as submit evidence of your counselling model and show how you adhere to the ethical framework. Whereas NCS offers accreditation if you have completed a course, are in practice and are a NCS member. Presently they say it is optional that you provide evidence of ethical practice or your counselling model. Confused about Accredited register and Accreditation? Have a look at Amanda Williamson article about the accreditation confusion at her article on this

The question that needs to be explored is whether these routes into membership be similar? Presently with BACP you need to actively demonstrate your counselling work but NCS you don’t.  NCS membership is cheaper than BACP. Price should not drive professionalism but for some maybe it does.

The debate of individual accreditation

Counsellors feel accreditation does not show you are a good counsellor. You can be experienced without it. It is true you can be a good counsellor without accreditation status but I feel accreditation gives you creditability. I see my accreditation the same as my husband’s chartered engineer status. Many engineers can have the title engineer without being chartered but when you see one is chartered you know they have been examined and recognised by their engineering body. Trust is instantly built.  For me, BACP accreditation says the same to the public. My own BACP Accreditation gave me a greater insight into myself and my role as a counsellor and I am thankful I took the time to complete it.

Split in the Counselling professionalism?

It feels as though there is beginning to be a split in the profession and I find this sad. We all want to protect our clients, promote their autonomy and help them. In the meantime I will stay a BACP member and adhere to their framework. The debate on regulation will continue. In the meantime I feel it is up to us and other mental health workers to raise the awareness to the public of the Register, so that clients can make the right choice in counsellor for them and know what credentials to look out for.

What are your views, so you want regulation?


1 thought on “Changes in Counselling Profession”

  1. I’m in the process of considering whether to join the NCS or the BACP. Looking at the NCS site, the NCS does have an equivalent to the BACP’s ‘accredited member’ status, and this is ‘accredited professional registrant’ where post-qualifying experience and development is assessed by the NCS.

    The NCS does not, I understand, have an equivalent of the BACP’s CoP (certificate of proficiency) which I understand is a relatively straight forward multiple choice question online assessment that qualified candidates need to do in order to become registered members.

    I’m more drawn to the ethos of the NCS as it emphasises being a member-led organisation.

    Both the NCS and BACP are registered with the Professional Standards Authority (PSA).

Leave a Reply